ideas-math-1.2: src/Domain/Math/Polynomial/BuggyBalance.hs
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
-- Copyright 2015, Open Universiteit Nederland. This file is distributed
-- under the terms of the GNU General Public License. For more information,
-- see the file "LICENSE.txt", which is included in the distribution.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
-- |
-- Maintainer : bastiaan.heeren@ou.nl
-- Stability : provisional
-- Portability : portable (depends on ghc)
--
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
-- $Id: BuggyBalance.hs 7527 2015-04-08 07:58:06Z bastiaan $
module Domain.Math.Polynomial.BuggyBalance
( buggyBalanceRules, buggyBalanceExprRules, buggyPriority
) where
import Control.Monad
import Data.Ratio
import Domain.Math.Data.Relation
import Domain.Math.Expr
import Domain.Math.Numeric.Views
import Domain.Math.Polynomial.BalanceUtils
import Domain.Math.Polynomial.Views
import Ideas.Common.Library
buggyBalanceRules :: [Rule (Equation Expr)]
buggyBalanceRules =
[ rule1234, rule201, rule2111, rule2112, rule2113, rule2114
, rule2121, rule2122, rule2131, rule2132, rule2133, rule2134
, rule2135, rule2136, rule2137, rule2138, rule2141, rule2142
, rule221, rule222, rule2232, rule2233
, rule311, rule322, rule2231, rule227, rule321, rule323
]
buggyBalanceExprRules :: [Rule Expr]
buggyBalanceExprRules =
[ rule121, rule122, rule1231, rule1232, rule1311, rule1312
, rule1314, rule1321, rule1322, rule133, rule134, rule135
, rule136, rule137
]
buggyPriority :: [Id]
buggyPriority =
[ getId rule1312, getId rule121, getId rule221, getId rule222
, getId rule2232, getId rule2233, getId rule227, getId rule323
]
-------------------------------------------------------------------
-- 1.2 Fout bij vermenigvuldigen
-- (a*b)/c -> a/(b*c)
rule121 :: Rule Expr
rule121 = describe "1.2.1: fout bij vermenigvuldigen" $
buggyBalanceExprRule "multiply1" f
where
f (expr :/: c) = do
(a, b) <- match timesView expr
return $ a/(b*c)
f _ = Nothing
-- a*(bx+c) -> x/(ab) + ac
rule122 :: Rule Expr
rule122 = describe "1.2.2: fout bij vermenigvuldigen" $
buggyBalanceExprRule "multiply2" f
where
f (a :*: expr) = do
((b, x), c) <- match (plusView >>> first timesView) expr
return $ x/(a*b) + a*c
f _ = Nothing
-- a(b-cx) -> ab+acx
rule1231 :: Rule Expr
rule1231 = describe "1.2.3.1: fout bij vermenigvuldigen; min raakt kwijt" $
buggyBalanceExprRule "multiply3" f
where
f (a :*: expr) = do
(b, (c, x)) <- match (minusView >>> second timesView) expr
return $ a*b+a*c*x
f _ = Nothing
-- -a*(x-b) -> -ax-ab
rule1232 :: Rule Expr
rule1232 = describe "1.2.3.2: fout bij vermenigvuldigen; min te veel" $
buggyBalanceExprRule "multiply4" f
where
f expr = do
(a, (x, b)) <- match (timesView >>> negView *** minusView) expr
return $ -a*x-a*b
-- -ax=b -> x=b/a
rule1234 :: Rule (Equation Expr)
rule1234 = describe "1.2.3.4: fout bij vermenigvuldigen; delen door negatief getal" $
buggyBalanceRule "multiply5" f
where
f (expr :==: b) = do
(a, x) <- match (timesView >>> first negView) expr
return $ x :==: b/a
-------------------------------------------------------------------
-- 1.3 Fout bij haakjes wegwerken
-- a(x-b) -> ax-b (verruimt naar +)
rule1311 :: Rule Expr
rule1311 = describe "1.3.1.1: fout bij haakjes wegwerken; haakjes staan er niet voor niets" $
buggyBalanceExprRule "par1" f
where
f expr = do
(a, (x, b)) <- match (timesView >>> second plusView) expr
return $ a*x+b
-- 1/a*(x-b) -> 1/a*x-b (specialized version of par1)
rule1312 :: Rule Expr
rule1312 = describe "1.3.1.2: fout bij haakjes wegwerken; haakjes staan er niet voor niets" $
buggyBalanceExprRule "par2" f
where
f (e1 :*: e2) = do
(n, a) <- match (divView >>> first integerView) e1
guard (n==1)
(x, b) <- match plusView e2
return $ 1/a*x+b
f _ = Nothing
-- a(b-cx) -> ab-cx
{- zie par1
rule1313 :: Rule (Equation Expr)
rule1313 = describe "1.3.1.3: fout bij haakjes wegwerken; haakjes staan e
r niet voor niets" $
buggyBalanceExprRule "par3") f
where
f (a :*: expr) = do
(b, (c, x)) <- match (minusView >>> second timesView) expr
return $ a*b-c*x
f _ = Nothing -}
-- -(a+b) -> -a+b
rule1314 :: Rule Expr
rule1314 = describe "1.3.1.4: fout bij haakjes wegwerken met unaire min; haakjes staan er niet voor niets" $
buggyBalanceExprRule "par11" f
where
f expr = do
(a, b) <- match (negView >>> plusView) expr
return $ -a+b
-- a(bx+c) -> ax+ac
rule1321 :: Rule Expr
rule1321 = describe "1.3.2.1: fout bij haakjes wegwerken; haakjes goed uitwerken" $
buggyBalanceExprRule "par4" f
where
f (a :*: expr) = do
((_, x), c) <- match (plusView >>> first timesView) expr
return $ a*x+a*c
f _ = Nothing
-- a(b-cx) -> ab-ax
rule1322 :: Rule Expr
rule1322 = describe "1.3.2.2: fout bij haakjes wegwerken; haakjes goed uitwerken" $
buggyBalanceExprRule "par5" f
where
f (a :*: expr) = do
(b, (_, x)) <- match (minusView >>> second timesView) expr
return $ a*b-a*x
f _ = Nothing
-- a(bx+c) -> bx+ac
rule133 :: Rule Expr
rule133 = describe "1.3.3: fout bij haakjes wegwerken; haakjes goed uitwerken" $
buggyBalanceExprRule "par6" f
where
f (a :*: expr) = do
((b, x), c) <- match (plusView >>> first timesView) expr
return $ b*x+a*c
f _ = Nothing
-- a-(b+c) -> a-b+c
rule134 :: Rule Expr
rule134 = describe "1.3.4: fout bij haakjes wegwerken; haakjes goed uitwerken" $
buggyBalanceExprRule "par7" f
where
f expr = do
(a, (b, c)) <- match (minusView >>> second plusView) expr
return $ a-b+c
-- a*(b-c)-d -> ab-ac-ad
rule135 :: Rule Expr
rule135 = describe "1.3.5: fout bij haakjes wegwerken; kijk goed waar de haakjes staan" $
buggyBalanceExprRule "par8" f
where
f expr = do
((a, (b, c)), d) <- match (minusView >>> first (timesView >>> second minusView)) expr
return $ a*b-a*c-a*d
-- a(bx+c) -> (a+b)x+ac
rule136 :: Rule Expr
rule136 = describe "1.3.6: fout bij haakjes wegwerken; haakjes goed uitwerken" $
buggyBalanceExprRule "par9" f
where
f (a :*: expr) = do
((b, x), c) <- match (plusView >>> first timesView) expr
return $ (a+b)*x+a*c
f _ = Nothing
-- a+b(x-c) -> (a+b)(x-c)
rule137 :: Rule Expr
rule137 = describe "1.3.7: fout bij haakjes wegwerken; denk aan 'voorrangsregels'" $
buggyBalanceExprRule "par10" f
where
f (a :+: expr) = do
(b, (x, c)) <- match (timesView >>> second plusView) expr
return $ (a+b)*(x+c)
f _ = Nothing
-------------------------------------------------------------------
-- 2.0 Links en rechts hetzelfde doen, of verwisselen
-- a=b-c -> c-b=a
rule201 :: Rule (Equation Expr)
rule201 = describe "2.0.1: Links en rechts alleen maar verwisseld?" $
buggyBalanceRule "flip1" f
where
f (a :==: rhs) = do
(b, c) <- match minusView rhs
return $ c-b :==: a
-------------------------------------------------------------------
-- 2.1 Links en rechts hetzelfde optellen/aftrekken
{-
schema addbal regels: (telkens paren met positief/negatief argument)
1+2 constante naar rechts
3+4 variabele naar links
7+8 variabele naar rechts
9+10 constante naar links
---
5/6 constante links weggehaald, maar rechts onveranderd gelaten
11/12 constante rechts weggehaald, maar links onveranderd gelaten
13/14 variabele links weggehaald, maar rechts onveranderd gelaten
15/16 variabele rechts weggehaald, maar links onveranderd gelaten
-}
-- ax+b=[cx]+d -> ax=[cx]+d+b
rule2111 :: Rule (Equation Expr)
rule2111 = describe "2.1.1.1: Links en rechts hetzelfde optellen; links +b en rechts -b" $
buggyBalanceRuleArg "addbal1" f
where
f ~(lhs :==: rhs) = do
~(ax, b) <- matchPlusCon lhs
guard (b>0)
termRef := fromRational b
return (ax :==: rhs+fromRational b)
-- ax-b=[cx]+d -> ax=[cx+d-b
rule2112 :: Rule (Equation Expr)
rule2112 = describe "2.1.1.2: Links en rechts hetzelfde optellen; links -b en rechts +b" $
buggyBalanceRuleArg "addbal2" f
where
f ~(lhs :==: rhs) = do
~(ax, b) <- matchPlusCon lhs
guard (b<0)
termRef := fromRational (abs b)
return (ax :==: rhs+fromRational b)
-- a=cx+d -> a+d=cx
rule2113 :: Rule (Equation Expr)
rule2113 = describe "2.1.1.3: Je trekt er rechts {?} vanaf, maar links tel je {?} erbij op." $
buggyBalanceRuleArg "addbal9" f
where
f ~(lhs :==: rhs) = do
~(cx, d) <- matchPlusCon rhs
guard (d>0)
termRef := fromRational d
return (lhs+fromRational d :==: cx)
-- a=cx-d -> a-d=cx
rule2114 :: Rule (Equation Expr)
rule2114 = describe "2.1.1.4: Je telt er rechts {?} bij op, maar links trek je {?} er vanaf." $
buggyBalanceRuleArg "addbal10" f
where
f ~(lhs :==: rhs) = do
~(cx, d) <- matchPlusCon rhs
guard (d<0)
termRef := fromRational (abs d)
return (lhs+fromRational d :==: cx)
-- ax[+b]=cx+d -> (a+c)x[+b]=d
rule2121 :: Rule (Equation Expr)
rule2121 = describe "2.1.2.1: Links en rechts hetzelfde optellen; links +cx en rechts -cx" $
buggyBalanceRuleArg "addbal3" f
where
f ~(lhs :==: rhs) = do
~(x, a, b) <- matchLin lhs
~(y, c, d) <- matchLin rhs
guard (c>0 && x==y)
termRef := fromRational c*x
return (fromRational (a+c)*x+fromRational b :==: fromRational d)
-- ax[+b]=-cx+d -> (a-c)x[+b]=d
rule2122 :: Rule (Equation Expr)
rule2122 = describe "2.1.2.2: Links en rechts hetzelfde optellen; links -cx en rechts +cx" $
buggyBalanceRuleArg "addbal4" f
where
f ~(lhs :==: rhs) = do
~(x, a, b) <- matchLin lhs
~(y, c, d) <- matchLin rhs
guard (c<0 && x==y)
termRef := fromRational (abs c)*x
return (fromRational (a+c)*x+fromRational b :==: fromRational d)
-- ax+b=cx+d -> b=(a+c)*x+d
rule2141 :: Rule (Equation Expr)
rule2141 = describe "2.1.4.1: Links en rechts hetzelfde optellen; links -ax en rechts +ax" $
buggyBalanceRuleArg "addbal7" f
where
f ~(lhs :==: rhs) = do
~(x, a, b) <- matchLin lhs
~(y, c, d) <- matchLin rhs
guard (a>0 && x==y)
termRef := fromRational a*x
return (fromRational b :==: fromRational (a+c)*x+fromRational d)
-- -ax+b=cx+d -> b=(-a+c)*x+d
rule2142 :: Rule (Equation Expr)
rule2142 = describe "2.1.4.2: Links en rechts hetzelfde optellen; links -cx en rechts +cx" $
buggyBalanceRuleArg "addbal8" f
where
f ~(lhs :==: rhs) = do
~(x, a, b) <- matchLin lhs
~(y, c, d) <- matchLin rhs
guard (a<0 && x==y)
termRef := fromRational (abs a)*x
return (fromRational b :==: fromRational (a+c)*x+fromRational d)
-- ax+b=e -> ax=e
rule2131 :: Rule (Equation Expr)
rule2131 = describe "2.1.3.1: Links en rechts hetzelfde optellen; links -b rechts niet(s)" $
buggyBalanceRuleArg "addbal5" f
where
f ~(lhs :==: rhs) = do
~(ax, b) <- matchPlusCon lhs
guard (b > 0)
termRef := fromRational b
return (ax :==: rhs)
-- ax-b=e -> ax=e
rule2132 :: Rule (Equation Expr)
rule2132 = describe "2.1.3.2: Links en rechts hetzelfde optellen; links +b en rechts niet(s)" $
buggyBalanceRuleArg "addbal6" f
where
f ~(lhs :==: rhs) = do
~(ax, b) <- matchPlusCon lhs
guard (b < 0)
termRef := fromRational (abs b)
return (ax :==: rhs)
-- e=ax+b -> e=ax
rule2133 :: Rule (Equation Expr)
rule2133 = describe "2.1.3.3: Links en rechts hetzelfde optellen; rechts -b links niet(s)" $
buggyBalanceRuleArg "addbal11" f
where
f ~(lhs :==: rhs) = do
~(ax, b) <- matchPlusCon rhs
guard (b > 0)
termRef := fromRational b
return (lhs :==: ax)
-- e=ax-b -> e=ax
rule2134 :: Rule (Equation Expr)
rule2134 = describe "2.1.3.4: Links en rechts hetzelfde optellen; rechts +b en links niet(s)" $
buggyBalanceRuleArg "addbal12" f
where
f ~(lhs :==: rhs) = do
~(ax, b) <- matchPlusCon rhs
guard (b < 0)
termRef := fromRational (abs b)
return (lhs :==: ax)
-- ax+b=e -> b=e
rule2135 :: Rule (Equation Expr)
rule2135 = describe "2.1.3.5: Links en rechts hetzelfde optellen; links -ax rechts niet(s)" $
buggyBalanceRuleArg "addbal13" f
where
f ~(lhs :==: rhs) = do
~(x, a, b) <- matchLin lhs
guard (a > 0)
termRef := fromRational a*x
return (fromRational b :==: rhs)
-- -ax+b=e -> b=e
rule2136 :: Rule (Equation Expr)
rule2136 = describe "2.1.3.6: Links en rechts hetzelfde optellen; links +ax en rechts niet(s)" $
buggyBalanceRuleArg "addbal14" f
where
f ~(lhs :==: rhs) = do
~(x, a, b) <- matchLin lhs
guard (a < 0)
termRef := fromRational (abs a)*x
return (fromRational b :==: rhs)
-- e=ax+b -> e=b
rule2137 :: Rule (Equation Expr)
rule2137 = describe "2.1.3.7: Links en rechts hetzelfde optellen; rechts -ax links niet(s)" $
buggyBalanceRuleArg "addbal15" f
where
f ~(lhs :==: rhs) = do
~(x, a, b) <- matchLin rhs
guard (a > 0)
termRef := fromRational a*x
return (lhs :==: fromRational b)
-- e=-ax+b -> e=b
rule2138 :: Rule (Equation Expr)
rule2138 = describe "2.1.3.8: Links en rechts hetzelfde optellen; rechts +ax en links niet(s)" $
buggyBalanceRuleArg "addbal16" f
where
f ~(lhs :==: rhs) = do
~(x, a, b) <- matchLin rhs
guard (a < 0)
termRef := fromRational (abs a)*x
return (lhs :==: fromRational b)
-------------------------------------------------------------------
-- 2.2 Links en rechts hetzelfde vermenigvuldigen/delen
-- ax=c -> x=a/c
rule221 :: Rule (Equation Expr)
rule221 = describe "2.2.1: Links en rechts hetzelfde vermenigvuldigen; verkeerd om gedeeld" $
buggyBalanceRule "mulbal1" f
where
f (expr :==: c) = do
(a, x) <- match timesView expr
return $ x :==: a/c
-- 1/*a+b=2/c*x+d -> x+ba -> 2x+cd
rule222 :: Rule (Equation Expr)
rule222 = describe "2.2.2: Links en rechts hetzelfde vermenigvuldigen; links *a; rechts *b" $
buggyBalanceRuleArg "mulbal2" f
where
f ~(lhs :==: rhs) = do
~(x, ra, b) <- matchLin lhs
~(y, rc, d) <- matchLin rhs
let a = denom ra
c = denom rc
denom = fromInteger . denominator
num = fromInteger . numerator
guard (a /= c && (a /= 1 || c /= 1))
factor1Ref := a
factor2Ref := c
return (num ra*x+fromRational b*a :==: num rc*y+c*fromRational d)
-- ax-b=cx+d -> pax-pb=cx+d
rule2231 :: Rule (Equation Expr)
rule2231 = describe "2.2.3.1: Links en rechts hetzelfde vermenigvuldigen; links *p, rechts niet (of andersom)" $
buggyBalanceRecognizer "mulbal3" p
where -- currently, symmetric
p ~(a1 :==: a2) ~(b1 :==: b2) = do
dl <- diffTimes a1 b1
dr <- diffTimes a2 b2
guard ((dl==1) /= (dr==1)) -- xor; only one of dl/dr equals 1
factorRef := if dr/=1 then dr else dl
-- (x+a)/b=c -> x+a=c
rule2232 :: Rule (Equation Expr)
rule2232 = describe "2.2.3.2: Links en rechts hetzelfde vermenigvuldigen; links /p, rechts niet" $
buggyBalanceRuleArg "mulbal4" f
where
f ~(expr :==: c) = do
~(a, b) <- matchM divView expr
factorRef := b
return (a :==: c)
-- a+b=c -> -a-b=c
rule2233 :: Rule (Equation Expr)
rule2233 = describe "2.2.3.3: Links en rechts hetzelfde vermenigvuldigen; links en rechts *-1" $
buggyBalanceRule "mulbal5" f
where
f (expr :==: c) = do
(a, b) <- match plusView expr
return $ -a-b :==: c
-- pa+pb=c -> a+b=c
rule227 :: Rule (Equation Expr)
rule227 = describe "2.2.7: Links en rechts hetzelfde vermenigvuldigen; een kant door p delen, andere kant niets" $
buggyBalanceRecognizer "mulbal6" p
where -- currently, symmetric
p ~(a1 :==: a2) ~(b1 :==: b2) = do
dl <- diffTimes a1 b1
dr <- diffTimes a2 b2
rl <- matchM rationalView dl
rr <- matchM rationalView dr
guard ( rl == 1 && rr /= 1 && numerator rr == 1 ||
rl /= 1 && rr == 1 && numerator rl == 1 )
factorRef := fromIntegral (denominator (if rr /= 1 then rr else rl))
-------------------------------------------------------------------
-- 3.1 Doe je wat je wilt doen?
-- ax-b=cx-d -> (c-a)x-b=-d
rule311 :: Rule (Equation Expr)
rule311 = describe "3.1.1: Doe je wat je wilt doen?" $
buggyBalanceRule "misc1" f
where
f (lhs :==: rhs) = do
(x, a, b) <- matchLin lhs
(y, c, d) <- matchLin rhs
guard (x==y)
return (fromRational (c-a)*x+fromRational b :==: fromRational d)
-- ax-b=cd+d -> pax-b=pcx+pd
rule321 :: Rule (Equation Expr)
rule321 = describe "3.2.1: Doe je wat je wilt doen? vermenigvuldig de hele linkerkant met p" $
buggyBalanceRecognizer "misc2" p
where -- currently, not symmetric
p ~(a1 :==: a2) ~(b1 :==: b2) = do
d <- diffTimes a2 b2
let as = from simpleSumView a1
guard (d `notElem` [1, -1] && length as > 1)
guard $ flip any (take (length as) [0..]) $ \i ->
let (xs,y:ys) = splitAt i as
aps = to sumView $ map (d*) xs ++ [y] ++ map (d*) ys
in viewEquivalent (polyViewWith rationalView) aps b1
factorRef := d
-- a-b=c -> -a-b=-c
rule322 :: Rule (Equation Expr)
rule322 = describe "3.2.2: Doe je wat je wilt doen? neem het tegengestelde van de hele linkerkant" $
buggyBalanceRule "misc3" f
where
f (expr :==: c) = do
(a, b) <- match minusView expr
return $ -a-b :==: -c
-- pax+pb=pc -> ax+pb=c
rule323 :: Rule (Equation Expr)
rule323 = describe "3.2.3: Doe je wat je wilt doen? Deel de hele linkerkant door p" $
buggyBalanceRecognizer "misc4" p
-- REFACTOR: code copied from rule misc2
where -- currently, not symmetric
p ~(a1 :==: a2) ~(b1 :==: b2) = do
d <- diffTimes a2 b2
dr <- matchM rationalView d
let as = from simpleSumView a1
guard (dr `notElem` [0, 1, -1] && numerator dr == 1 && length as > 1)
guard $ flip any (take (length as) [0..]) $ \i ->
let (xs,y:ys) = splitAt i as
aps = to sumView $ map (d*) xs ++ [y] ++ map (d*) ys
in viewEquivalent (polyViewWith rationalView) aps b1
factorRef := fromRational (1/dr)